MPs raise questions in UK Parliament over arrest of Tibet protestors

[27 October 2015] The arrest of the three peaceful protestors during the Chinese President’s State Visit last week was raised in parliament yesterday via an Urgent Question submitted by Fabian Hamilton MP. The Minister responsible for policing, Mike Penning, refused to comment on the matter citing that it was “an ongoing police investigation”, but then came under increasing pressure as MPs lined up to criticise the decision to arrest the protestors.

Tibet Society, as Secretariat for the All Party Parliamentary Group for Tibet, worked with Fabian Hamilton MP to raise the Urgent Question and provided a synopsis of the protests and arrests to MPs.

Statement | Watch online | Quotes from MPs | Background

Tibet Society statement
The arrests of three peaceful protestors during the Chinese President’s State Visit to the UK are a very serious breach of the rights of British citizens to legitimately protest. The actions of the police raise questions as to where the orders for the arrests and home raids emanated. The circumstances leading to the arrests must be investigated and any collusion with Chinese security made public. The UK police must not be allowed to become a puppet of the Chinese State.

Watch the parliament debate via parliament.tv (26 mins)

 

Arrest of Tibet protestors raised in Parliament

Fabian Hamilton (Leeds North East) (Lab) raised the issue of the arrest of Tibet protestors during the Chinese President’s State Visit as an Urgent Question following parliamentary regular business on 26 October 2015. The Minister for Policing, Crime and Criminal Justice, Mike Penning, responded on behalf of the government. The issue, including subsequent comments and questions by MPs, was discussed for almost 30 minutes before the Speaker brought the matter to a close.

Mr Hamilton’s Urgent Question: “To ask the Minister to make a statement on the arrests of three peaceful protesters during President Xi Jinping’s visit to London last week.”

The Minister for Policing, Crime and Criminal Justice, Mike Penning responded saying, “It would be inappropriate for me to comment on specific individual cases.” The Minister added, “The right to protest peacefully is guaranteed under UK law, but protesters’ rights need to be balanced with the right of others to go about their business without fear of intimidation or serious disruption to the community. Rights to peaceful protest do not extend to violent, threatening behaviour, and the police have the powers to deal with such acts. The Metropolitan police issued a statement on this issue last week; they reject any suggestion that they acted inappropriately.”

Mr Hamilton then provided some details on the arrests and individuals arrests, noting Sonam Choden was “arrested for attempting to display a Tibetan flag” and Shao Jiang for “trying to display two A4-sized placards protesting against China’s human rights abuses”. He then asked the Minister if he would “comment on why their homes were searched at night while they were in custody?”

Mr Penning refused to answer, saying it was “not a matter for the Police Minister to comment on”.

MPs from all sides of the House then lined up to support the protestors and to question the Minister further. To these questions Mr Penning continued to reply that he could not comment on an ongoing investigation. During which time he appeared to be getting redder and redder in the face.

A selection of quotes follows:
Jack Dromey (Birmingham, Erdington) (Lab): “In a free society, we defend the right to dissent and to protest.” adding that Mr Hamilton “is absolutely right to raise these concerns on the Floor of the House of Commons.”

Dr Tania Mathias (Twickenham) (Con): “Does he share my shame at the purported harassment of a Tiananmen Square survivor, Dr Shao Jiang?”

Anne McLaughlin (Glasgow North East) (SNP): Asked the Minister if he could “think of any reason, hypothetically speaking, why somebody waving their country’s flag should lead to them being arrested, put behind bars and having their mobile phone and PC taken from them?”

Mr David Winnick (Walsall North) (Lab): “It is unfortunate that he appears to be an apologist for [the arrests], as it seems to many people that what took place, as far as the police were concerned, could be described as British police action with Chinese characteristics.”

Tim Loughton (East Worthing and Shoreham) (Con) tried a different tact, asking, “Will the Minister tell me how freedom of expression was equitably allowed by police who corralled peaceful Tibetan demonstrators at the back of the Mall with a line of police officers in front of them while pro-Chinese demonstrators, wearing T-shirts issued by the Chinese embassy, were allowed prime position at the front?”

Matthew Pennycook (Greenwich and Woolwich) (Lab) & Emily Thornberry (Islington South and Finsbury) (Lab) both raised concerns on behalf of their constituents, Sonam Choden and Dr Shao Jiang respectively. Ms Thornberry said the decision to arrest her constituent was “disgraceful”.

Ann Clwyd (Cynon Valley) (Lab) said she was “embarrassed… a peaceful demonstration was treated in such a way.”

Mr Alistair Carmichael (Orkney and Shetland) (LD) noted that when “the execution of these operational matters is done in such a way as to risk a chilling effect on freedom of speech, that becomes a matter for this House.”

Andy Slaughter (Hammersmith) (Lab) called on the Minister to “properly investigate” the circumstances leading to the arrests.

Further comments were made by Mark Pritchard (The Wrekin) (Con), Ms Gisela Stuart (Birmingham, Edgbaston) (Lab), Mr Dennis Skinner (Bolsover) (Lab), Mr Barry Sheerman (Huddersfield) (Lab/Co-op), Mike Gapes (Ilford South) (Lab/Co-op), and Mrs Madeleine Moon (Bridgend) (Lab)..

Click here to read the full text of debate via Hansard

Background on protests and arrests

On 21 October, two Tibetans and a Chinese human rights defender were arrested for peacefully protesting during the Chinese President’s State Visit to the UK. Whilst in custody, their homes were raided by the police and computer equipment confiscated.

The three individuals had done nothing more than engage in their legitimate right to peaceful protest, which is a basic right upheld in British law.

It is clear from responses to the arrests that many members of the public are also deeply concerned about the government appearing to bend over backwards to provide a platform for the leader of the Chinese Communist Party at the cost of the public’s rights and privacy.

The three, Dr Shao Jiang (above), Sonam Choden (right) and Jamphel Lhamo (below), were arrested in two separate incidents. They were initially arrested to ‘prevent a breach of the peace’ under Section 5 of the Public Order Act. Later, when at the Bishopsgate Police Station, all three were arrested on ‘suspicion of conspiracy to commit threatening behaviour’.

The police used undue force when arresting Dr Shao Jiang who, whilst standing on his own in the road with two A4 sized placards calling for human rights for the people of China, was tackled to the ground by more than five police officers. Footage of his arrest was very clearly filmed and has been shown on the BBC, Channel 4 and other media outlets.

A little later, Sonam Choden and Jamphel Lhamo, were arrested for attempting to wave a Tibetan flag at the passing cavalcade of cars.

Mr Bill Nash, from BSB solicitors who represents the two Tibetan women, said, “In 40 years of legal experience I have never heard of police arresting peaceful protesters for conspiring to contravene Section 5 of the Public Order Act, which concerns harassment or threatening behaviour.”

Two days earlier, during the procession on The Mall to welcome Xi Jinping, many human rights protesters were completely swamped by thousands of Chinese students who surrounded, harassed and intimidated anyone who raised a placard or Tibetan flag. The police stood by and did nothing to protect the protesters from such threatening behaviour.

This was evident from a letter published in The Independent from Carole Beavis from Derbyshire. Carole, who had come to London to support groups campaigning for Tibet and human rights in China, spoke of her shock at, “the scale and level of organisation of the Chinese “welcome” that accompanied the President’s every move”.

When she took her Tibetan flag outside of the cordon she was, “subjected to aggressive bullying by Chinese men carrying huge flags which they used to cover and hide ours. We then had the attention of the Chinese dragon dancers, whilst the drummers and cymbal-bashers crashed next to our ears in an effort to intimidate us and drown out our legitimate voices.”

She then attempted to film the noisemakers but “was singled out by three official-looking Chinese men, who effectively herded me away from the event and lowered my arm holding the camera. I stood next to a policeman and told him I felt threatened, and they immediately backed off but stood a short distance away taking photos of the demonstrators, including me.”

This eyewitness account about the lack of response to protect legitimate peaceful protesters from orchestrated intimidation only adds to the concerns over the validity of the arrests of Dr Shao Jiang, Sonam Choden and Jamphel Lhamo, and raises serious questions over the even-handedness of the police approach.

Dr Shao Jiang, Sonam Choden and Jamphel Lhamo have been arrested under Section 5 of the Public Order Act. There is no inference of any potential violent act being prevented. Had this been the case they would have been arrested under Section 4 of the Public Order Act (unlawful violence).

To raid people’s homes, seize their computers and other electronic equipment for alleged breach of the peace, is unwarranted and borders on a violation of privacy. To send eight police officers to one home, five to another and use keys taken from one of those arrested to enter his home is disproportionate. Moreover, it is a very questionable use of police time and resources.

Answers need to be given to questions posed by Dr Shao Jiang and his wife Johanna Zhang when they say, “We would like to know more about the decision-making process that led to both the arrest and the seizure of our computers. We would also like to know when our computers will be returned.”

Further reading:
Tibet Society report (23 Oct)
Two Tibetans arrested during Xi Jinping UK visit; homes raided
BBC (23 Oct): Met Police defends ‘heavy-handed’ arrest of Chinese protesters
Independent (22 Oct): UK accused of doing China’s bidding…
Independent (22 Oct): I protested against China during its state visit to London…
Guardian (23 Oct): Xi Jinping protesters arrested and homes searched…
Daily Mail: (24 Oct) It’s like being back in China says Tiananmen survivor…

Mother of two self-immolates in Chone

04 February 2018
Mother of two self-immolates in Chone

[5 June 2015] Sangye Tso (pictured right, also referred to as Sangyal Tso) set herself ablaze around 4am local time on 27 May in front of a government office located within Tashi...

Tibet to be debated in UK Parliament on Thursday 18 June

04 February 2018

A backbench debate on Tibet will be held in Parliament at 1.30pm on Thursday 18 June. The debate will be led by Fabian Hamilton MP (Lab, Leeds North East). Ask your...

UK parliament debates Tibet; government lacklustre in its response

04 February 2018

[19 June 2015] On 18 June, the UK Parliament held its first debate on Tibet since the General Election. Though many issues were raised and questions asked of the government, the...

Family ordered to lie following self-immolation; five detained

04 February 2018

[24 June 2015] UPDATE: The husband of self-immolator Sangye Tso has been detained by the Chinese authorities. Tamding Wangyal was arrested on 10 June along with a local monk, Trinley Gyatso....

The Dalai Lama to headline Glastonbury!

04 February 2018
The Dalai Lama to headline Glastonbury!

We can finally reveal the rumuors are true. The Dalai Lama will be appearing at the Glastonbury this weekend! The Dalai Lama will be giving a talk in the Green...

The Dalai Lama brings happiness to Glastonbury

04 February 2018
The Dalai Lama brings happiness to Glastonbury

The Dalai Lama visited the UK for four days at the end of June 2015. The trip included a first-time visit to the Glastonbury festival, a public talk in Aldershot...

China: End the repression of Uyghurs in East Turkestan

04 February 2018

On the eve of the 6th anniversary of the Urumqi massacre, Uyghurs and human rights activists in the UK are calling upon the Chinese government to investigate the events of...

Dalai Lama birthday celebrations banned in Tibet; three detained

04 February 2018
Dalai Lama birthday celebrations banned in Tibet; three detained

Three Tibetans have been detained by Chinese police in Tibet for attempting to celebrate the Dalai Lama’s 80th birthday. In the run-up to the anniversary, local authorities banned religious events,...

Tenzin Delek Rinpoche dies in Chinese prison

04 February 2018
Tenzin Delek Rinpoche dies in Chinese prison

On 12 July 2015, the Chinese authorities announced the highly revered Tibetan leader Tenzin Delek Rinpoche died in prison. Tenzin Delek Rinpoche had been imprisoned on false charges and was...

MP says ‘China has Tenzin Delek Rinpoche’s blood on its hands’

04 February 2018
MP says ‘China has Tenzin Delek Rinpoche’s blood on its hands’

[Tibet Society press release: 13 July 2015] Tibet Society is greatly saddened and outraged by the news of the death of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche who died in a Chinese prison on...

Tibetans protest over death of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche

04 February 2018
Tibetans protest over death of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche

On 13 July, following the death of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche, over a thousand Tibetans gathered in Nyagchuka (Chinese: Yajiang) county, Kardze (Ch: Ganzi) prefecture, Kham (now incorporated into China’s Sichuan...

Lack of official information on Rinpoche’s death

04 February 2018
Lack of official information on Rinpoche’s death

Though Tenzin Delek Rinpoche’s death has been confirmed by Chinese officials, the exact date of the death and the circumstances are still not clear. Associated Press reported on 13 July...

Rinpoche denied visits from family

04 February 2018

Tenzin Delek Rinpoche was last seen by his family during a prison visit in November 2013. This was one of only seven prison visits allowed durng his 13 years in...

Self-immolation in Tibet following Dalai Lama’s birthday

04 February 2018

[14 July 2015] On 9 July, a Tibetan monk self-immolated in a public square in eastern Tibet. Sonam Topgyal was quickly apprehended by local authorities and is believed to be in...

Update on protests in Tibet; at least 15 injured

04 February 2018
Update on protests in Tibet; at least 15 injured

Latest reports indicate at least 15 Tibetans were injured as Chinese security forces violently dispersed protesters calling for the release of the body of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche. The protests took...

UK & US government statements on death of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche

04 February 2018

The UK government issued a statement late on 13 July via a Foreign Office spokesperson saying, “We are saddened by reports that Tenzin Delek Rinpoche has died in detention in China....

Chinese authorities cremate Tenzin Delek Rinpoche’s body

04 February 2018

The Chinese authorities have cremated the body of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche against the wishes of his family. Some members of his family were allowed to attend the cremation, which was...

Sisters of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche temporarily detained

04 February 2018

According to International Campaign for Tibet, two sisters of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche, were detained by the Chinese authorities after they refused to sign a document about his health condition. The...

Tenzin Delek Rinpoche’s ashes confiscated

04 February 2018

Following the cremation of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche on 16 July, the authorities handed over the ashes to his family. A group of four Tibetans then began the journey back to...

Sister and niece of Tulku detained

04 February 2018

The sister of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche, Dolkar Lhamo and her daughter, Nyima Lhamo, were detained by the Chinese authorities on 17 July in Chengdu, Sichuan province. Dolkar Lhamo, 52, had...

State media say Tenzin Delek Rinpoche’s death was due to heart attack

04 February 2018

A week after Tenzin Delek’s death the Chinese authorities announced that he had died from a heart attack. According to a statement issued on 18 July by the state-run news...

Sister and niece of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche released

04 February 2018
Sister and niece of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche released

The sister and niece of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche were released after two weeks of detention on July 31. Dolkar Lhamo, 52, sister of Tenzin Delek, and her daughter Nyima, 25,...

Tibetan nomad Runggye Adak released after eight year prison sentence

04 February 2018
Tibetan nomad Runggye Adak released after eight year prison sentence

Runggye Adak, one of Tibet’s most well-known political prisoners, was released from Mianyang prison on 30 July 2015 after serving an eight-year prison sentence for publicly calling for Tibetan freedom...

Chinese President calls for “anti-separatism battle” in Tibet

04 February 2018
Chinese President calls for “anti-separatism battle” in Tibet

Chinese President Xi Jinping has called for greater efforts to fight “anti-separatist” activities in Tibet as preparations are being made for the upcoming 50th anniversary of the founding of the...

Mother of five self-immolates after house demolition

04 February 2018
Mother of five self-immolates after house demolition

A Tibetan mother of five has died following a self-immolation protest in Tibet. The protest came shortly after Chinese authorities forcibly demolished a nearby property belonging to a Tibetan. It...

Spate of arrests in Tibet as China celebrates 50th anniversary of TAR

04 February 2018
Spate of arrests in Tibet as China celebrates 50th anniversary of TAR

As the Chinese government celebrated the 50th anniversary of the founding of the Tibet Autonomous Region, Tibetans continued to demonstrate against decades of repressive policies and the lack of human...

Protests against Chinese rule continue in Tibet

04 February 2018
Protests against Chinese rule continue in Tibet

Tibetans continue to publicly protest against China’s repressive policies despite tightened security and the risk of severe punishment. Following a series of protests around China’s celebration of the 50th anniversary...

Press Release: Own Goal for Liverpool Football Club as it Endorses Chinese Water Company

04 February 2018

(London) – On 24 July, Liverpool FC entered into an agreement with a Chinese company involved in resource exploitation in Tibet. Now Tibet Society, the world's oldest Tibet support group,...

Direct Action: Tibetan activist groups meet with supporters outside the Liverpool FC vs Watford match

04 February 2018
Direct Action: Tibetan activist groups meet with supporters outside the Liverpool FC vs Watford match

On 12 August, Tibet Society in collaboration with a range of other Tibetan activist groups and supporters, headed to the opening of the premier league at Watford Stadium. As supporters...

“Tibet Society has a special place in the hearts of His Holiness the Dalai Lama and the Tibetan people. We wish them the very best.”

04 February 2018
“Tibet Society has a special place in the hearts of His Holiness the Dalai Lama and the Tibetan people. We wish them the very best.”

You can read our September  2017 Update here “Tibet Society has a special place in the hearts of His Holiness the Dalai Lama and the Tibetan people. We wish them the...

APPG on Tibet – Autumn Update

04 February 2018

On 23 November 2017, Sikyong Dr Lobsang Sangay, the President of the Tibetan Government-in-Exile, gave a briefing and held a discussion with MPs at the Houses of Parliament in Westminster,...

Letter to the Prime Minister on Human Rights Day

04 February 2018

Prime Minister Theresa May10 Downing StreetLondonSW1A 2AA 10 December 2017 Dear Prime Minister May, Tibetan Uyghur & Chinese Solidarity UK is writing to you today on International Human Rights Day...

Press Release: Tibetan Uyghur & Chinese Solidarity UK call for renewed efforts to combat human rights violations in China

04 February 2018

[10 December 2017] On Human Rights Day, Tibetan Uyghur & Chinese Solidarity UK [1] is calling on the UK and international community to take “immediate and bold action” to address...

Press Release: President Emmanuel Macron must raise Tashi Wangchuk’s case during visit to China

04 February 2018

Tibet Society is calling on French President Emmanuel Macron to use next week’s visit to China to raise the case of Tashi Wangchuk, a young Tibetan shopkeeper who has been detained...

Sunday: Mobile Billboard Calling on Liverpool FC Owner to Drop Controversial Deal With Chinese Company, Tibet Water, to tour the city ahead of Manchester City Match

04 February 2018

Over 80,000 have demanded that Liverpool FC owner John W. Henry cancels deal with Tibet Water due to human rights abuses A campaign led by Tibet groups and international consumer...

« »

About Tibet House

Tibet Society is the world’s first ever Tibet support group. The Society was founded in 1959, within weeks of the flight of the Dalai Lama from Tibet following the uprising against China's occupation. Today, the organisation continues to work actively for the freedom of the Tibetan people and their right to self-determination.

Search