UK parliament debates Tibet; government lacklustre in its response

[19 June 2015] On 18 June, the UK Parliament held its first debate on Tibet since the General Election. Though many issues were raised and questions asked of the government, the response received from the Foreign Minister was lacklustre, revealing little beyond the fact that some issues had been “raised” with Chinese counterparts and others would be “monitored”. There was almost no criticism of Chinese policies in Tibet; instead, at one point, the Minister actually praised China for its efforts in ‘developing’ Tibet.

On a more positive note, Mr Swire (Minister of State for the Foreign Office) did call on China to release Tenzin Delek Rinpoche on medical parole. He also encouraged “better governance” of China’s mining industry operating in the Tibet Autonomous Region.

In response to questions over the UK’s policy on Tibet and a call for the UK to support the Tibetan people’s right to self-determination, Mr Swire stated, “The clear position of the British Government that Tibet is part of the People’s Republic of China, and that we do not support Tibetan independence.” Disappointingly, there was no mention of the UK government seeking “genuine autonomy” for Tibet, which used to be part of the policy.

Summary of debate I Government’s response I Transcript of debate


Summary of debate
The backbench debate, held in the secondary debating chamber, was led by Fabian Hamilton (Labour MP for Leeds North East and Chair of the All Party Parliamentary Group for Tibet).

Mr Hamilton began with reference to the 800th anniversary of the signing of the Magna Carta, saying it was timely “to remind ourselves of the practical applications of those values and to illustrate our commitment” by considering the people of Tibet, “whose rights have been violated and abused, and who might expect this Parliament, this country and our Government to speak out for them, to give them the voice that they are systematically denied.”

Mr Hamilton said that China, having created the Tibet Autonomous Region (TAR), “have done everything in their power to undermine that autonomy and to destroy the ethnic and cultural identity of Tibet.” He then went on to give various examples including the mass migration of Han Chinese to Tibet, the lack of education in the Tibetan language and repression of religion.

Mr Hamilton stated, “Events in Tibet have global implications, and that by failing to speak out against the political, environmental and economic oppression in the TAR, we risk allowing a bully to influence world events and undermine our values.”

A number of political prisoner cases were raised by Mr Hamilton, including those of the Panchen Lama, Tenzin Delek Rinpoche and Thardoe Gyaltsen (the latter was jailed for 18 years for possessing copies of the Dalai Lama’s teachings). Mr Hamilton urged the government to speak out and press China on these cases. He also asked, “How can the United Kingdom strengthen its policies on Tibet, so as to take a clear stance on the essential issue of human rights?”

Mr Hamilton noted China’s hypocrisy of repressing language and culture in Tibet whilst promoting its own language and culture globally via Confucius Institutes. Mr Hamilton said these Institutes “actively undermine western support for Tibet and Taiwan” and questioned their staffing policies which do not conform to UK and EU employment law.

Environmental issues were also highlighted, including climate change on the Tibetan plateau, the damming of rivers and exploitation of Tibet’s natural resources, as well protests by Tibetans on these issues and the forced relocation of Tibet’s nomadic population.

China’s new Foreign NGO Management Law, currently being drafted, was scrutinised. Mr Hamilton said the law “seeks to restrict the activities of foreign NGOs” which will have a “massive impact” on the work of NGOs in China and Tibet.

Mr Hamilton encouraged the UK government to extend the Chevening Scholarship scheme to help Tibetans refugees enter degree programmes in the UK.

In conclusion, Mr Hamilton said that we should value the Dalai Lama’s messages of peace and compassion and “stand up more strongly to the bullying tactics of those who continue to oppress the Tibetan people and vilify His Holiness the Dalai Lama”.

Tim Loughton (Conservative MP for East Worthing and Shoreham), during an intervention, highlighted the discrepancy between China’s constitution and its actions. “Is it not ironic that the Chinese constitution recognises the diverse culture and heritage of the various peoples who make up the People’s Republic of China?” Mr Loughton continued, “China is clearly failing to recognise and protect the culture, heritage and, indeed, language of the Tibetan people, which is being destroyed at the hands of the Chinese Government.”

Nic Dakin (Labour MP for Scunthorpe) reiterated China’s failings in Tibet by adding, “If China is to be a truly modern state… it needs to step up to the plate and behave in a way that recognises the human rights of others.”

Opposition response
Patrick Grady
 (MP for Glasgow North) responded on behalf of the SNP. Mr Grady noted the work of the Cross Party Group for Tibet in the Scottish Parliament. He said the Scottish Parliament “very clearly condemned human rights abuses” following a debate on Tibet in 2014. He also stated that one of the four guiding principles in the Scottish government’s engagement strategy with China was “respecting human rights and the rule of law, supporting China’s process of modernisation and internal reform, and the need to balance the demands of economic development with social justice.”

Kerry McCarthy (Labour MP for Bristol East) responded to the debate as Shadow Minister to the Foreign Office. Ms McCarthy began by stating that “China must recognise that a more authoritarian approach [on Tibet] will not strengthen its sovereignty; it will only diminish its moral authority.”

Ms McCarthy noted the human rights abuses that China continues to undertake in Tibet, which attempt to undermine the Tibetan identity. In particular, Ms McCarthy said the recent self-immolations are “a harrowing indictment of human rights in Tibet”. She added, “Criminalising bereaved relatives is not preventing the self-immolations. The solution is dialogue with the Dalai Lama’s representatives and an end to repressive practices.”

Ms McCarthy said the UK must “work constructively with China” but that “we cannot let that work inhibit us when it comes to universal principles of human rights.”

The upcoming State Visit of Chinese President Xi Jinping in October was questioned by Ms McCarthy. She asked, “Was the decision to invite the President a response to agreement from the Chinese Government on any areas of concern?”

The Shadow Foreign Minister also asked questions regarding media and diplomatic access to Tibet, mining operations in Tibet and if Tibet was part of the international climate dialogue.

Government response
Hugo Swire, the Minister of State for the Foreign and Commonwealth Office whose responsibility includes Tibet and China, responded on behalf of the government.

Mr Swire began by noting the UK’s position on Tibet. “The clear position of the British Government is that Tibet is part of the People’s Republic of China, and that we do not support Tibetan independence.”

Before any acknowledgment of the serious Tibetan human rights cases or China’s ongoing repression of Tibetan culture and religion, Mr Swire had the audacity to praise China. As if reading direct from a Chinese propaganda leaflet Mr Swire said, “I am pleased to report that rapid economic growth has raised living standards across China and has improved access to a range of social and economic rights. In Tibet, investment in education, healthcare and employment has led to a doubling in life expectancy since the early 1950s.”

Only after praising the Chinese government did Mr Swire state the UK’s “long-standing concerns” over ethnic minority rights, freedom of religion or belief, and freedom of expression, all of which Mr Swire said “should be protected under the Chinese constitution”.

Mr Swire noted the case of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche was raised during the UK-China Human Rights Dialogue in April. He then took the opportunity to “urge the Chinese authorities to ensure that, while detained, all such people have access to adequate medical care or, in severe cases such as Tenzin’s, are released on medical parole.”

The Foreign Minister expressed the government’s belief that “meaningful dialogue” is the “best way to address and resolve the underlying differences between Tibetan communities and the Chinese Government” and pointed out this was raised during discussions with the Chinese Government. However, Mr Swire failed to inform the chamber on China’s response, as was the case when he mentioned the raising of other issues.

Mr Swire said the government “continue(s) to press for access to the Tibetan autonomous region” (for media and diplomats) and supports calls “for the relevant authorities to facilitate a meeting between the Panchen Lama and independent international observers”.

In response to questions on concerns over mining in Tibet, Mr Swire stated, “We… encourage the adoption of better governance in the extractive industries. It is important that high standards are applied throughout China, including in the Tibetan autonomous region, and by Chinese companies operating internationally.”

On Confucius Institutes, Mr Swire said the government is “not aware of any evidence to suggest that they are compromising those principles in the UK, but we remain alert to any impropriety or allegations of impropriety”.

Read full transcript of the debate

Join our Network

Mother of two self-immolates in Chone

04 February 2018
Mother of two self-immolates in Chone

[5 June 2015] Sangye Tso (pictured right, also referred to as Sangyal Tso) set herself ablaze around 4am local time on 27 May in front of a government office located within Tashi...

Tibet to be debated in UK Parliament on Thursday 18 June

04 February 2018

A backbench debate on Tibet will be held in Parliament at 1.30pm on Thursday 18 June. The debate will be led by Fabian Hamilton MP (Lab, Leeds North East). Ask your...

UK parliament debates Tibet; government lacklustre in its response

04 February 2018

[19 June 2015] On 18 June, the UK Parliament held its first debate on Tibet since the General Election. Though many issues were raised and questions asked of the government, the...

Family ordered to lie following self-immolation; five detained

04 February 2018

[24 June 2015] UPDATE: The husband of self-immolator Sangye Tso has been detained by the Chinese authorities. Tamding Wangyal was arrested on 10 June along with a local monk, Trinley Gyatso....

The Dalai Lama to headline Glastonbury!

04 February 2018
The Dalai Lama to headline Glastonbury!

We can finally reveal the rumuors are true. The Dalai Lama will be appearing at the Glastonbury this weekend! The Dalai Lama will be giving a talk in the Green...

The Dalai Lama brings happiness to Glastonbury

04 February 2018
The Dalai Lama brings happiness to Glastonbury

The Dalai Lama visited the UK for four days at the end of June 2015. The trip included a first-time visit to the Glastonbury festival, a public talk in Aldershot...

China: End the repression of Uyghurs in East Turkestan

04 February 2018

On the eve of the 6th anniversary of the Urumqi massacre, Uyghurs and human rights activists in the UK are calling upon the Chinese government to investigate the events of...

Dalai Lama birthday celebrations banned in Tibet; three detained

04 February 2018
Dalai Lama birthday celebrations banned in Tibet; three detained

Three Tibetans have been detained by Chinese police in Tibet for attempting to celebrate the Dalai Lama’s 80th birthday. In the run-up to the anniversary, local authorities banned religious events,...

Tenzin Delek Rinpoche dies in Chinese prison

04 February 2018
Tenzin Delek Rinpoche dies in Chinese prison

On 12 July 2015, the Chinese authorities announced the highly revered Tibetan leader Tenzin Delek Rinpoche died in prison. Tenzin Delek Rinpoche had been imprisoned on false charges and was...

MP says ‘China has Tenzin Delek Rinpoche’s blood on its hands’

04 February 2018
MP says ‘China has Tenzin Delek Rinpoche’s blood on its hands’

[Tibet Society press release: 13 July 2015] Tibet Society is greatly saddened and outraged by the news of the death of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche who died in a Chinese prison on...

Tibetans protest over death of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche

04 February 2018
Tibetans protest over death of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche

On 13 July, following the death of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche, over a thousand Tibetans gathered in Nyagchuka (Chinese: Yajiang) county, Kardze (Ch: Ganzi) prefecture, Kham (now incorporated into China’s Sichuan...

Lack of official information on Rinpoche’s death

04 February 2018
Lack of official information on Rinpoche’s death

Though Tenzin Delek Rinpoche’s death has been confirmed by Chinese officials, the exact date of the death and the circumstances are still not clear. Associated Press reported on 13 July...

Rinpoche denied visits from family

04 February 2018

Tenzin Delek Rinpoche was last seen by his family during a prison visit in November 2013. This was one of only seven prison visits allowed durng his 13 years in...

Self-immolation in Tibet following Dalai Lama’s birthday

04 February 2018

[14 July 2015] On 9 July, a Tibetan monk self-immolated in a public square in eastern Tibet. Sonam Topgyal was quickly apprehended by local authorities and is believed to be in...

Update on protests in Tibet; at least 15 injured

04 February 2018
Update on protests in Tibet; at least 15 injured

Latest reports indicate at least 15 Tibetans were injured as Chinese security forces violently dispersed protesters calling for the release of the body of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche. The protests took...

UK & US government statements on death of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche

04 February 2018

The UK government issued a statement late on 13 July via a Foreign Office spokesperson saying, “We are saddened by reports that Tenzin Delek Rinpoche has died in detention in China....

Chinese authorities cremate Tenzin Delek Rinpoche’s body

04 February 2018

The Chinese authorities have cremated the body of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche against the wishes of his family. Some members of his family were allowed to attend the cremation, which was...

Sisters of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche temporarily detained

04 February 2018

According to International Campaign for Tibet, two sisters of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche, were detained by the Chinese authorities after they refused to sign a document about his health condition. The...

Tenzin Delek Rinpoche’s ashes confiscated

04 February 2018

Following the cremation of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche on 16 July, the authorities handed over the ashes to his family. A group of four Tibetans then began the journey back to...

Sister and niece of Tulku detained

04 February 2018

The sister of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche, Dolkar Lhamo and her daughter, Nyima Lhamo, were detained by the Chinese authorities on 17 July in Chengdu, Sichuan province. Dolkar Lhamo, 52, had...

State media say Tenzin Delek Rinpoche’s death was due to heart attack

04 February 2018

A week after Tenzin Delek’s death the Chinese authorities announced that he had died from a heart attack. According to a statement issued on 18 July by the state-run news...

Sister and niece of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche released

04 February 2018
Sister and niece of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche released

The sister and niece of Tenzin Delek Rinpoche were released after two weeks of detention on July 31. Dolkar Lhamo, 52, sister of Tenzin Delek, and her daughter Nyima, 25,...

Tibetan nomad Runggye Adak released after eight year prison sentence

04 February 2018
Tibetan nomad Runggye Adak released after eight year prison sentence

Runggye Adak, one of Tibet’s most well-known political prisoners, was released from Mianyang prison on 30 July 2015 after serving an eight-year prison sentence for publicly calling for Tibetan freedom...

Chinese President calls for “anti-separatism battle” in Tibet

04 February 2018
Chinese President calls for “anti-separatism battle” in Tibet

Chinese President Xi Jinping has called for greater efforts to fight “anti-separatist” activities in Tibet as preparations are being made for the upcoming 50th anniversary of the founding of the...

Mother of five self-immolates after house demolition

04 February 2018
Mother of five self-immolates after house demolition

A Tibetan mother of five has died following a self-immolation protest in Tibet. The protest came shortly after Chinese authorities forcibly demolished a nearby property belonging to a Tibetan. It...

Spate of arrests in Tibet as China celebrates 50th anniversary of TAR

04 February 2018
Spate of arrests in Tibet as China celebrates 50th anniversary of TAR

As the Chinese government celebrated the 50th anniversary of the founding of the Tibet Autonomous Region, Tibetans continued to demonstrate against decades of repressive policies and the lack of human...

Protests against Chinese rule continue in Tibet

04 February 2018
Protests against Chinese rule continue in Tibet

Tibetans continue to publicly protest against China’s repressive policies despite tightened security and the risk of severe punishment. Following a series of protests around China’s celebration of the 50th anniversary...

Press Release: Own Goal for Liverpool Football Club as it Endorses Chinese Water Company

04 February 2018

(London) – On 24 July, Liverpool FC entered into an agreement with a Chinese company involved in resource exploitation in Tibet. Now Tibet Society, the world's oldest Tibet support group,...

Direct Action: Tibetan activist groups meet with supporters outside the Liverpool FC vs Watford match

04 February 2018
Direct Action: Tibetan activist groups meet with supporters outside the Liverpool FC vs Watford match

On 12 August, Tibet Society in collaboration with a range of other Tibetan activist groups and supporters, headed to the opening of the premier league at Watford Stadium. As supporters...

“Tibet Society has a special place in the hearts of His Holiness the Dalai Lama and the Tibetan people. We wish them the very best.”

04 February 2018
“Tibet Society has a special place in the hearts of His Holiness the Dalai Lama and the Tibetan people. We wish them the very best.”

You can read our September  2017 Update here “Tibet Society has a special place in the hearts of His Holiness the Dalai Lama and the Tibetan people. We wish them the...

APPG on Tibet – Autumn Update

04 February 2018

On 23 November 2017, Sikyong Dr Lobsang Sangay, the President of the Tibetan Government-in-Exile, gave a briefing and held a discussion with MPs at the Houses of Parliament in Westminster,...

Letter to the Prime Minister on Human Rights Day

04 February 2018

Prime Minister Theresa May10 Downing StreetLondonSW1A 2AA 10 December 2017 Dear Prime Minister May, Tibetan Uyghur & Chinese Solidarity UK is writing to you today on International Human Rights Day...

Press Release: Tibetan Uyghur & Chinese Solidarity UK call for renewed efforts to combat human rights violations in China

04 February 2018

[10 December 2017] On Human Rights Day, Tibetan Uyghur & Chinese Solidarity UK [1] is calling on the UK and international community to take “immediate and bold action” to address...

Press Release: President Emmanuel Macron must raise Tashi Wangchuk’s case during visit to China

04 February 2018

Tibet Society is calling on French President Emmanuel Macron to use next week’s visit to China to raise the case of Tashi Wangchuk, a young Tibetan shopkeeper who has been detained...

Sunday: Mobile Billboard Calling on Liverpool FC Owner to Drop Controversial Deal With Chinese Company, Tibet Water, to tour the city ahead of Manchester City Match

04 February 2018

Over 80,000 have demanded that Liverpool FC owner John W. Henry cancels deal with Tibet Water due to human rights abuses A campaign led by Tibet groups and international consumer...

« »

About Tibet House

Tibet Society is the world’s first ever Tibet support group. The Society was founded in 1959, within weeks of the flight of the Dalai Lama from Tibet following the uprising against China's occupation. Today, the organisation continues to work actively for the freedom of the Tibetan people and their right to self-determination.

Search